IS監査担当者は、ITマネージャーがコスト削減のために最近SaaS(Software as a Service)プロバイダーとの契約を変更したことを発見しました。新しい契約では、インシデントの解決に要する時間が増加しています。監査担当者が最も懸念すべき事項は次のうちどれでしょうか?
正解:C
The correct answer is C. The impact on business processes has not been evaluated.
The auditor's greatest concern is not simply that the contract became cheaper or that incident resolution time increased. The key concern is whether management evaluated the business impact of the longer incident resolution time. A longer incident resolution period may affect system availability, customer service, operational processing, contractual commitments, regulatory obligations, or business continuity.
ISACA defines a service level agreement as an agreement between a service provider and customer that defines minimum performance targets for a service and how those targets will be measured. ISACA's CISA Exam Content Outline includes IT vendor management, IT service level management, problem and incident management, and evaluating whether IT service management practices align with organizational requirements.
Option A may be a concern if the new contract violates security policy, but the question does not state that it does. Option B is not the greatest concern because failing to consider alternative cost reductions is a management efficiency issue, not the primary audit risk. Option D is a concern because the SLA should match the contract, but updating the SLA alone does not solve the more important issue: whether the changed incident response commitment is acceptable to the business.
In CISA terms, IT decisions should be evaluated based on business impact and alignment, not only cost savings. A cheaper SaaS contract may create unacceptable operational risk if slower incident resolution affects critical business processes.
References: ISACA CISA Exam Content Outline, Domains 2 and 4; ISACA Interactive Glossary, "Service level agreement."